Health Battleground
Categories : General Practice, News, Politics |
Allow me to get a little bit political for a few moments … It’s good to see that health has finally opened up as a bit of a battleground for the upcoming election, after a couple of fairly quiet years on the health policy front. This was sparked off by Kevin Rudd’s headline grabbing “policies” of a federal takeover of state hospitals and something called GP “super clinics.” There’s been plenty written about the former idea and all the potential problems associated with it (including maybe an increased GST) but not much press on the Super Clinics. Like most of Rudd’s policies to date, it seems to be a flashy title designed to beguile the public and make Rudd seem like a sensible man of action, yet has very little substance behind it. As if building these new clinics is going to address the problems of a nationwide doctor shortage and overcrowded emergency departments. Where are they going to get these doctors from? If they manage to attract doctors to shift into these practices (and so far the only “incentive” I have seen mentioned is a $15,000 payment which really won’t attract many GPs at all, especially if these clinics are to be bulk-billing clinics which would actually reduce most GPs’ income)… but even if they can attract GPs to work there, aren’t they just shifting the problem from one place to another, making it even harder to get appointments in the practices the doctors woul be forsaking? When there’s only a limited pool of doctors, building new clinics won’t go a long way towards solving the problem, they need to add to the pool of doctors… HOW? only two possibilities spring to mind - one is increasing the medical school intake, which the Howard Govt has already done, but which is a long term solution only since it will be years before these new docs are practicing. Or secondly increasing the amount of foreign doctors allowed to work here, but this is both morally ambiguous (since we might be “stealing” doctors from other countries who need them even more) and slightly dodgy politically (after the recent doctor terrorist scare) and medically (since it’s hard to assure the quality of medicine practiced). So Super Clinics is all headline (don’t you just love the word “Super”!) but no substance. But hopefully it will have the effect of upping the ante and making health a bigger issue in the upcoming election. Hopefully the government can come up with a better plan than Rudd’s efforts so far.
